Noescio
Home › Sessions › Why units must be standard

Why units must be standard

Class 9Science Units and measurementSession 3 Free

A measurement is a number and a unit. Units are fixed by international agreement so that a kilogram is the same everywhere. One airliner ran out of fuel because a unit was mixed up.

A number alone is not a measurement

“Bring 2” is not an instruction you can follow. Two kilograms, two litres and two packets are different amounts.

A measurement is a number together with a unit. The unit is the agreed amount you are counting in. The number says how many of those units there are. In “2 kg”, the unit is the kilogram and the number is 2.

A shopkeeper in one town uses a particular stone as his “1 kg” weight. A shopkeeper in the next town uses a different stone. What goes wrong?

The two stones almost certainly have different masses. So “2 kg of rice” is a different amount of rice in each town.

Neither customer can check the amount, because there is nothing both towns agree on to compare against. A unit is only useful if everyone measures against the same reference.

LOCAL STONES · UNFAIR “1 kg” in town A “1 kg” in town B ONE AGREED STANDARD · FAIR 1 kg The same everywhere, for everyone.

Why standards exist. With local objects as weights, two measurements of “1 kg” can differ and nobody can check which is right. A unit has to be defined by one reference that everyone agrees on.

One system for everyone

Standard units do two separate jobs:

The system used in science worldwide is the SI, from the French Système international d’unités. It has seven base units. Four of them are the metre (length), the kilogram (mass), the second (time) and the ampere (electric current). Since 2019, each base unit is defined from a fixed constant of nature. The kilogram, for example, is defined from the Planck constant, so any well-equipped laboratory can reproduce it.

Air Canada Flight 143, 1983

A Boeing 767 needed 22,300 kg of fuel for its flight. The fuel gauges were not working, so the ground crew measured the fuel in the tanks in litres and converted to mass using its density.

They used a density of 1.77. That number is the density in pounds per litre. The calculation needed kilograms per litre, which is 0.80. Because 1 pound is 0.4536 kg, the aircraft carried about 22,300 pounds of fuel, which is about 10,100 kg. That is less than half of what it needed.

The engines stopped at 12,500 m. The pilots glided the aircraft to a disused airfield at Gimli and landed. Nobody was killed.

Load the aircraft yourself

The aircraft needs 22,300 kg of fuel. Pick the unit the ground crew uses for the density of the fuel.

FUEL NEEDED
22,300 kg loaded
Correct unit. The aircraft has the fuel it needs.

In that incident, the crew did the multiplications correctly. Why did the aircraft still run out of fuel?

The number was right for one unit and used as if it were another. 1.77 is correct in pounds per litre. Treated as kilograms per litre, it gives a mass about 2.2 times too large, so too little fuel was added.

Writing the unit beside every number, at every step, makes this mismatch visible. “1.77 lb/L × litres” gives pounds, not kilograms, and the error shows.

Three habits for your own work

Check what you have understood

1Why are units fixed by international agreement?

Agreed units make results comparable between laboratories and keep amounts in buying and selling the same wherever they are measured.

2The SI base unit of mass is the ____.

The kilogram, not the gram, is the SI base unit of mass. Since 2019 it is defined from the Planck constant.

3In the Flight 143 incident, what went wrong?

1.77 lb/L was treated as 1.77 kg/L. The correct value was 0.80 kg/L. The computed mass of fuel on board was therefore about 2.2 times too large, so too little was added.

4A student writes “the speed is 12”. What is missing?

12 m/s and 12 km/h differ by a factor of 3.6. Without the unit, the number cannot be used.

5Sort each unit: is it an SI base unit or not?

Metre
Pound
Second
Kilogram
Metre, second and kilogram are SI base units. The pound is from the imperial system; 1 lb = 0.4536 kg.

6Which statement is correct?

A measurement is a number and a unit. The same number with a different unit is a different amount.

7A student adds a length in metres to a time in seconds. What should you conclude?

Only quantities of the same kind can be added. Length and time are different kinds, so no conversion makes the sum meaningful.

Next: what scientists mean by a law, a theory and a principle.

‹ Previous: The language of science Next: Laws, theories and principles ›